THE TRUTH ABOUT E-COLLARS IN DOG TRAINING || Ivan Balabanov debunks the myths surrounding e-collars
Ivan BalabanovIvan Balabanov · 영상 · 11분
전자식 칼라를 활용하여 다수의 반려견을 통제하고 야외에서 자유롭게 활동하게 한다. 통제권을 확보하고 돌발적인 공격성을 사전에 방지함으로써 반려견들이 안전하고 평화롭게 어울릴 수 있는 환경을 조성한다. 전자식 칼라가 반려견에게 트라우마나 공포를 유발한다는 주장을 반박하며, 적절한 활용은 반려견의 정서나 외양, 상호작용 방식에 부정적인 영향을 미치지 않는다고 본다. 오히려 일관된 한계 설정과 통제는 반려견에게 안정감을 제공하고 사회적 환경에서 더 나은 반응을 끌어낸다. 훈련사는 수십 년의 경험을 바탕으로 전자식 칼라를 도구로서 정확히 사용하고 보호하는 것의 중요성을 강조한다. 무분별한 맹신이나 부정보다는 실제 행동 교정과 안전 확보를 위한 실용적인 도구 활용에 집중한다.
THE TRUTH ABOUT E-COLLARS IN DOG TRAINING || Ivan Balabanov debunks the myths surrounding e-collars
0:00
people who use this disgust me because there are so many other ways to teach dogs regardless of the issue that your dog has many are so traumatized even by one experience of shock that it causes a lifetime of fear so [Music] these are some of my dogs like seven malinois intact not paid not neuter that's a five-year-old male that's also hit by this the stud dog there is a female that with a frisbee that has a electric collar or a shock collar on her two-year-old this one here these two are young they're about nine months old this one with the ball here he has a shock collar also on him and the reason i have colors on them there is only two dolls with colors the reason we have colors or them is so i can control them so i know that there is no retaliation so i know that they can play i know that i can set up limits for them and i know that i can be responsible for what is going on and there will be no fights there will be no bullying around nobody's gonna jump on somebody and start a fight for a toy or for whatever other reason um so the dogs are very highly trained some of them the obviously the nine month old ones they are not trained at all but the older dogs are very very well trained they are competition dogs they they are you know some of them are been to world championships um and so on so it's not a matter of how much i know about training dogs i've been training those for 30 years i'm two times world champion i've been working as a guide dog instructor i've been animal behaviors in the shelter i know how to train dogs but i also like to have control and i like to come out in the morning and let them all out and have a peace of mind that there will be no fights and no aggression and that they can just roam free and enjoy every day um hey come here ice this way if i did not have electric collars on some of the dogs i will feel very uncomfortable letting them do what they do right now but this is called the remote collar e-collar or shock collar
3:56
and it's designed to give your dog a shock of static electricity if your dog does something you don't like the thing is there will be no uh nothing that can convince you that those dogs right now that you're seeing are stressed that they've been shocked and they're affected for their life for life from now on or that they are afraid of me or afraid of the other dogs or anything in the surroundings um it does not work like this with electric collars you can have victoria stillwell or jean donaldson or all of those people tell you how dangerous how horrible and and how you should never ever ever use it and if you don't feel comfortable then you don't use them but as i said i would hope that that day is not gonna come where i'm not gonna be able to let my dogs roam free and know that i have control i would hate to be able to just let dogs one or two at a time on long lines and not give them the freedom and the fun of being free so as i said that's that's really what i wanted to show you there is these two are with the electric collars on there is no way you can tell any difference in their demeanor in their appearance in the way they walk the way they interact with everybody else that they are affected because they wear electric collars if anything they also feel a little bit more at ease and just the fact that they're under control makes them a better dog in the park now having said that word park it's also uh um you know we can go there we can call it a pack leader a dominant whatever it doesn't matter i am the person that is in control and they follow my rules so whatever you want to call that that's fine with me but i will allow them at some point to have some confrontation if they can sort things out very easy with a little nip that's fine but i will never allow them to escalate into a dog fight i hope this is clear i hope you understand that those devices are not the horrible thing that they are portrayed by the force-free community people and um i i really hope that we can pass that point and we can prevent and protect the use of the electric collars in a proper way so our dogs and we can benefit from that which is clearly the case in that situation
7:54
if the use of the electric collar would cause an aggression at this point i will have a big mess in my hands here of seven dogs fighting most people who use these kind of things when training have no idea of this psychological negative impact it's having on their dog it's pretty cool isn't it okay guys let's go back mia come on well i can tell you that numerous studies have been done to show how dogs react to these kind of shock collars [Music] [Music] i'm i have to step in there because i believe that any trainer or owner who uses a dominance submission methodology that's medieval dog training the best scientists and mythologists and behaviorists in this country agree that to train your dog in a positive manner gives it confidence and security yeah but it's not your way or the highway he has his way we're not crying and that's no no no no no i totally disagree with you you're not the end-all be-all everyone hates their own way of training you're the god of dogs yes i am because i follow the very best in this country i mean i'm not just ridiculous do you know what do not say i'm ridiculous and i'm going to get very angry with you i didn't say you were asking you are saying that i am ridiculous get over yourself i'm sorry that is very insulting [Music] [Applause] [Music]
0:03
people who use this disgust me because people who use this disgust me because there are so many other ways to teach there are so many other ways to teach there are so many other ways to teach dogs regardless of the issue that your dogs regardless of the issue that your dogs regardless of the issue that your dog has dog has dog has many are so traumatized even by one many are so traumatized even by one many are so traumatized even by one experience of shock experience of shock experience of shock that it causes a lifetime of fear so so [Music] these are some of my dogs like these are some of my dogs like seven malinois intact seven malinois intact seven malinois intact not paid not neuter not paid not neuter not paid not neuter that's a five-year-old male that's also that's a five-year-old male that's also that's a five-year-old male that's also hit by this hit by this hit by this the stud dog there is a the stud dog there is a the stud dog there is a female that with a frisbee that has a female that with a frisbee that has a female that with a frisbee that has a electric collar electric collar electric collar or a shock collar on her or a shock collar on her or a shock collar on her two-year-old two-year-old two-year-old this one here these two are young this one here these two are young this one here these two are young they're about nine months old this one with the ball here he has a this one with the ball here he has a shock collar also on him shock collar also on him shock collar also on him and the reason i have colors on them and the reason i have colors on them and the reason i have colors on them there is only two dolls with colors there is only two dolls with colors there is only two dolls with colors the reason we have colors or them is so the reason we have colors or them is so the reason we have colors or them is so i can control them so i can control them so i can control them so i know that there is no retaliation so i i know that there is no retaliation so i i know that there is no retaliation so i know that they can play know that they can play know that they can play i know that i can set up limits for them i know that i can set up limits for them i know that i can set up limits for them and i know that i can be responsible for and i know that i can be responsible for and i know that i can be responsible for what is going on what is going on what is going on and there will be no fights there will and there will be no fights there will and there will be no fights there will be no bullying around be no bullying around be no bullying around nobody's gonna jump on somebody and
2:02
nobody's gonna jump on somebody and nobody's gonna jump on somebody and start a fight start a fight start a fight for a toy or for whatever other reason um so the dogs are very highly trained um so the dogs are very highly trained some of them some of them some of them the obviously the nine month old ones the obviously the nine month old ones the obviously the nine month old ones they are not trained at all they are not trained at all they are not trained at all but the older dogs are but the older dogs are but the older dogs are very very well trained they are very very well trained they are very very well trained they are competition dogs competition dogs competition dogs they they are you know some of them are they they are you know some of them are they they are you know some of them are been to world championships um and so on been to world championships um and so on been to world championships um and so on so it's not a matter of how much i know so it's not a matter of how much i know so it's not a matter of how much i know about about about training dogs i've been training those training dogs i've been training those training dogs i've been training those for 30 years i'm two times for 30 years i'm two times for 30 years i'm two times world champion i've been working world champion i've been working world champion i've been working as a guide dog instructor i've been as a guide dog instructor i've been as a guide dog instructor i've been animal behaviors in the shelter i know animal behaviors in the shelter i know animal behaviors in the shelter i know how to train how to train how to train dogs but i also dogs but i also dogs but i also like to have control like to have control like to have control and i like to come out in the morning and i like to come out in the morning and i like to come out in the morning and and and let them all out and have a peace of let them all out and have a peace of let them all out and have a peace of mind mind mind that there will be no fights and no that there will be no fights and no that there will be no fights and no aggression aggression aggression and that they can just roam free and that they can just roam free and that they can just roam free and enjoy every day if i did not have electric collars if i did not have electric collars on some of the dogs i will feel very on some of the dogs i will feel very on some of the dogs i will feel very uncomfortable uncomfortable uncomfortable letting them do what they do right now letting them do what they do right now letting them do what they do right now but this is called the remote collar but this is called the remote collar
3:54
but this is called the remote collar e-collar or shock collar e-collar or shock collar e-collar or shock collar and it's designed to give your dog a and it's designed to give your dog a and it's designed to give your dog a shock of static electricity shock of static electricity shock of static electricity if your dog does something you don't if your dog does something you don't if your dog does something you don't like the thing like the thing like the thing is there will be no uh nothing is there will be no uh nothing is there will be no uh nothing that can convince you that those dogs that can convince you that those dogs that can convince you that those dogs right now that you're seeing right now that you're seeing right now that you're seeing are stressed that they've been shocked are stressed that they've been shocked are stressed that they've been shocked and they're and they're and they're affected for their life for life from affected for their life for life from affected for their life for life from now on now on now on or that they are afraid of me or afraid or that they are afraid of me or afraid or that they are afraid of me or afraid of the other dogs or anything of the other dogs or anything of the other dogs or anything in the surroundings it does not work like this with electric it does not work like this with electric collars collars collars you can have victoria stillwell or you can have victoria stillwell or you can have victoria stillwell or jean donaldson or all of those people jean donaldson or all of those people jean donaldson or all of those people tell you how dangerous how horrible tell you how dangerous how horrible tell you how dangerous how horrible and and how you should never and and how you should never and and how you should never ever ever use it and if you don't feel ever ever use it and if you don't feel ever ever use it and if you don't feel comfortable then you don't use them comfortable then you don't use them comfortable then you don't use them but as i said i would hope but as i said i would hope but as i said i would hope that that day is not gonna come where that that day is not gonna come where that that day is not gonna come where i'm not gonna be able to let my dogs i'm not gonna be able to let my dogs i'm not gonna be able to let my dogs roam free and know that i have control roam free and know that i have control roam free and know that i have control i would hate to be able to just i would hate to be able to just i would hate to be able to just let dogs one or two at a time let dogs one or two at a time
5:25
let dogs one or two at a time on long lines and not give them the on long lines and not give them the on long lines and not give them the freedom freedom freedom and the fun of being free so as i said that's that's really what i so as i said that's that's really what i wanted to show you wanted to show you wanted to show you there is these two are with the electric there is these two are with the electric there is these two are with the electric collars on collars on collars on there is no way you can tell any there is no way you can tell any there is no way you can tell any difference difference difference in their demeanor in their appearance in in their demeanor in their appearance in in their demeanor in their appearance in the way they walk the way they interact the way they walk the way they interact the way they walk the way they interact with everybody else with everybody else with everybody else that they are affected because they wear that they are affected because they wear that they are affected because they wear electric collars if anything electric collars if anything electric collars if anything they also feel a little bit more at ease they also feel a little bit more at ease they also feel a little bit more at ease and just the fact that they're under and just the fact that they're under and just the fact that they're under control control control makes them a better dog in the park makes them a better dog in the park makes them a better dog in the park now having said that word park now having said that word park now having said that word park it's also uh um you know it's also uh um you know it's also uh um you know we can go there we can call it a pack we can go there we can call it a pack we can go there we can call it a pack leader leader leader a dominant whatever it doesn't matter i a dominant whatever it doesn't matter i a dominant whatever it doesn't matter i am the person am the person am the person that is in control and they follow that is in control and they follow that is in control and they follow my rules so whatever you want to call my rules so whatever you want to call my rules so whatever you want to call that that's fine with me that that's fine with me that that's fine with me but i will allow them at some point but i will allow them at some point but i will allow them at some point to have some confrontation if they can to have some confrontation if they can to have some confrontation if they can sort things out sort things out sort things out very easy with a little nip that's fine very easy with a little nip that's fine
6:57
very easy with a little nip that's fine but i will never allow them to escalate but i will never allow them to escalate but i will never allow them to escalate into a dog fight i hope this is clear i hope you i hope this is clear i hope you understand understand understand that those devices are not that those devices are not that those devices are not the horrible thing that they are the horrible thing that they are the horrible thing that they are portrayed by the force-free community portrayed by the force-free community portrayed by the force-free community people people people and um and um and um i i really hope that we can pass that i i really hope that we can pass that i i really hope that we can pass that point point point and we can prevent and protect and we can prevent and protect and we can prevent and protect the use of the electric collars in a the use of the electric collars in a the use of the electric collars in a proper proper proper way so our dogs and we can benefit from way so our dogs and we can benefit from way so our dogs and we can benefit from that that that which is clearly the case in that which is clearly the case in that which is clearly the case in that situation if the use of the electric collar if the use of the electric collar would cause an aggression at this point would cause an aggression at this point would cause an aggression at this point i will have a big i will have a big i will have a big mess in my hands here mess in my hands here mess in my hands here of seven dogs fighting of seven dogs fighting of seven dogs fighting most people who use these kind of things most people who use these kind of things most people who use these kind of things when training when training when training have no idea of this psychological have no idea of this psychological have no idea of this psychological negative impact it's having on their dog okay guys let's go back mia okay guys let's go back mia come on well i can tell you that numerous well i can tell you that numerous studies have been done to show studies have been done to show studies have been done to show how dogs react to these kind of shock collars collars [Music] [Music] [Music] i'm i have to step in there because i i have to step in there because i believe that any trainer believe that any trainer believe that any trainer or owner who uses a dominance or owner who uses a dominance or owner who uses a dominance submission methodology that's medieval submission methodology that's medieval submission methodology that's medieval dog training dog training dog training the best scientists and mythologists and
9:53
the best scientists and mythologists and the best scientists and mythologists and behaviorists in this country behaviorists in this country behaviorists in this country agree that to train your dog in a agree that to train your dog in a agree that to train your dog in a positive manner positive manner positive manner gives it confidence and security yeah gives it confidence and security yeah gives it confidence and security yeah but it's not your way or the highway he but it's not your way or the highway he but it's not your way or the highway he has his way we're not crying and that's has his way we're not crying and that's has his way we're not crying and that's no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no i totally disagree with you you're not i totally disagree with you you're not i totally disagree with you you're not the end-all be-all the end-all be-all the end-all be-all everyone hates their own way of training everyone hates their own way of training everyone hates their own way of training you're the god of dogs you're the god of dogs you're the god of dogs yes i am because i follow the very best yes i am because i follow the very best yes i am because i follow the very best in this country in this country in this country i mean i'm not just ridiculous do you i mean i'm not just ridiculous do you i mean i'm not just ridiculous do you know what do not say i'm ridiculous and know what do not say i'm ridiculous and know what do not say i'm ridiculous and i'm going to get very angry with you i i'm going to get very angry with you i i'm going to get very angry with you i didn't say you were didn't say you were didn't say you were asking you are saying that i am asking you are saying that i am asking you are saying that i am ridiculous get over yourself ridiculous get over yourself ridiculous get over yourself i'm sorry that is very insulting i'm sorry that is very insulting i'm sorry that is very insulting [Music] [Music] [Music] [Applause]